This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
In the complex world of American presidential elections, where thousands of counties cast their votes every four years, two unlikely places have emerged as perfect predictors of national outcomes. Blaine County, Montana, and Essex County, New York have correctly voted for the winning presidential candidate in every election since 2000, making them the nation’s only remaining “perfect” bellwether counties.
The Remarkable Story of Blaine County
Tucked away in north-central Montana, Blaine County might seem like an unlikely political oracle. With just over 7,000 residents, this rural county has demonstrated an almost supernatural ability to align with the national mood. What’s even more remarkable is its historical track record – Blaine County has voted for the winning presidential candidate in every election since its founding in 1912, with just one exception: the 1988 election.
During that year, amidst a severe drought that devastated local agriculture, the county backed Democratic candidate Michael Dukakis over George H.W. Bush by a mere 58 votes. This interruption of its perfect streak actually tells us something important about the county’s voting patterns – they’re deeply connected to local economic conditions and agricultural interests.
The county’s population is approximately 50% Native American, primarily from the Fort Belknap Reservation (home to the Assiniboine/Nakoda and Gros Ventre peoples) and the Little Shell Chippewa Tribe service area. The largest town, Chinook, has just 1,200 residents, while the second-largest, Harlem, has about 800. Ranching and agriculture drive the local economy, with most land either privately owned or part of the reservation.
Essex County: The Northeast’s Crystal Ball
Essex County, New York presents a different picture entirely. Located in the Adirondack Mountains, this county of 38,000 people has transformed from a Republican stronghold into a reliable national indicator. Before the 1990s, Essex County was so consistently Republican that it had voted Democratic only once since the Civil War (excluding 1964, when Barry Goldwater lost every county in New York State).
The county’s shift mirrors broader national trends in political realignment. Since 1996, Essex has swung between parties just as the nation has, backing George W. Bush (2000, 2004), Barack Obama (2008, 2012), Donald Trump (2016, 2024), and Joe Biden (2020). Home to Lake Placid of “Miracle on Ice” fame, the county combines tourism-dependent communities with traditional farming areas and vast stretches of protected wilderness in the Adirondack High Peaks.
What Makes These Counties Special?
Some might dismiss these counties’ predictive powers as mere statistical coincidence. After all, with 3,144 counties in the United States, some are bound to have winning streaks by chance alone. However, the consistency of these two counties, especially Blaine’s century-long record, suggests there might be more to the story.
Both counties share some interesting characteristics:
They’re relatively rural but not isolated
They have diverse economic bases (agriculture, tourism, government services)
They maintain strong connections to both traditional industries and modern economic forces
They include significant federal lands and tribal territories (in Blaine’s case)
The End of an Era?
The 2024 election actually marked the end of several notable bellwether streaks. Door County, Wisconsin, and Clallam County, Washington, both lost their perfect records. This highlights how rare and remarkable the continuing accuracy of Blaine and Essex counties really is.
Looking Ahead
Will these counties maintain their predictive streak in 2028 and beyond? Only time will tell. But one thing is certain – political analysts and election watchers will be paying close attention to these two small but remarkably prescient places when the next presidential election rolls around.
What do you think makes these counties such reliable predictors of national elections? Have you visited either of these places? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.
